Live Meta Sync

RDR2 Complete Weapons Database

Updated for Patch 1.32

Last Check: Mar 19, 2024

All firearms, bows, and melee weapons mapped with damage and RPM statistics.

Fire Bottle VS Throwing Knife

Frontier Mechanics Comparison

Fire Bottle

Throwable

Throwing Knife

Throwable

Winner

🏆 Throwing Knife

Fire Bottle	Stat	Throwing Knife
✓ 75	Base Damage	60
20	RPM	40 ✓
25	DPS	40 ✓
50	Accuracy	50
50	Movement Speed	50
0%	Armor Pen	0%
6.000s	TTK (Close)	4.500s ✓
✓ 3	Shots to Kill	4
2.00x	HS Multiplier	2.00x
6	Magazine	6
2.000s	Reload Speed	2.000s

📊 TTK by Range

Close Range6.000s

Medium Range6.000s

Long Range9.000s

Fire Bottle

Throwing Knife

🎯 Scenario Breakdown

Close Range (0-10m)

Throwing Knife

Throwing Knife has a 1.500s faster TTK

Medium Range (10-30m)

Throwing Knife

Better damage retention at medium distance

Long Range (30m+)

Throwing Knife

Superior long-range damage retention

Against Armor (40%)

Throwing Knife

Faster time-to-kill through armor

📊 Detailed Analysis: Fire Bottle vs Throwing Knife in Red Dead Redemption 2

A deeper dive into the Fire Bottle and Throwing Knife reveals distinct advantages. The time-to-kill battle goes to the Throwing Knife (4.500s vs 6.000s). In the DPS category, the Throwing Knife secures the win with 40 DPS to 25. Securing an elimination takes 3 rounds from the Fire Bottle and 4 from the Throwing Knife.

Mobility & Handling: Both weapons operate at similar movement speeds — positioning and cover usage matter more than weapon weight here.

Situational Use: The Throwing Knife excels in aggressive push scenarios where TTK dictates the outcome, while the Fire Bottle may outperform in defensive long-range holds with its different damage profile.

Data summary: Throwing Knife wins on TTK by 1500ms and on DPS by 15 points. In most standard encounters, these margins are what determine the outcome when both players have equal aim.

Fire Bottle Rivals

FIRE-BOTTLE vs DYNAMITE→FIRE-BOTTLE vs TOMAHAWK→FIRE-BOTTLE vs THROWING-KNIFE→

Throwing Knife Rivals

THROWING-KNIFE vs DYNAMITE→THROWING-KNIFE vs TOMAHAWK→THROWING-KNIFE vs FIRE-BOTTLE→

Weapon Familiarity and Condition

Weapons perform better the more you use them.

Stat Ratings

Damage

Base power before ammo modifiers.

Ammo Types

Express ammo provides a sheer damage boost.

Frequently Asked Questions

Most damage?+

The Elephant Rifle hits the hardest.

Methodology & Data Integrity

All calculations are based on verified data extracted from Red Dead Redemption 2 Patch 1.32 game files. We cross-reference values with in-game testing to ensure 99.9% accuracy for competitive play.