Live Meta Sync

RDR2 Complete Weapons Database

Updated for Patch 1.32

Last Check: Mar 19, 2024

All firearms, bows, and melee weapons mapped with damage and RPM statistics.

Carcano Rifle VS Navy Revolver

Frontier Mechanics Comparison

Carcano Rifle

Sniper

Navy Revolver

Revolver

Winner

🏆 Navy Revolver

Carcano Rifle	Stat	Navy Revolver
✓ 85	Base Damage	45
40	RPM	150 ✓
57	DPS	113 ✓
50	Accuracy	50
50	Movement Speed	50
0%	Armor Pen	0%
3.000s	TTK (Close)	1.600s ✓
✓ 3	Shots to Kill	5
2.00x	HS Multiplier	2.00x
6	Magazine	6
2.000s	Reload Speed	2.000s

📊 TTK by Range

Close Range3.000s

Medium Range3.000s

Long Range4.500s

Carcano Rifle

Navy Revolver

🎯 Scenario Breakdown

Close Range (0-10m)

Navy Revolver

Navy Revolver has a 1.400s faster TTK

Medium Range (10-30m)

Navy Revolver

Better damage retention at medium distance

Long Range (30m+)

Navy Revolver

Superior long-range damage retention

Against Armor (40%)

Carcano Rifle

Faster time-to-kill through armor

📊 Detailed Analysis: Carcano Rifle vs Navy Revolver in Red Dead Redemption 2

Mobility & Handling: Neither weapon dominates in mobility — both options allow similar rotational flexibility in engagements. Breaking down the Carcano Rifle against the Navy Revolver shows the Navy Revolver securing the fastest TTK (1.600s compared to 3.000s). When we evaluate raw damage per second, the Navy Revolver shines with 113 DPS versus 57. The Carcano Rifle needs 3 lethal hits; the Navy Revolver needs 5.

Squad Role: In squad contexts, the Navy Revolver fits best as an entry fragger given its elimination profile. For cover and support roles, consider the range characteristics of the alternative weapon.

Ultimately, the Navy Revolver provides a mathematically superior profile, meaning it will win more 50/50 duels when shots are traded equally.

Carcano Rifle Rivals

CARCANO-RIFLE vs RARE-ROLLING-BLOCK-RIFLE→CARCANO-RIFLE vs ROLLING-BLOCK-RIFLE→

Navy Revolver Rivals

NAVY-REVOLVER vs RARE-ROLLING-BLOCK-RIFLE→NAVY-REVOLVER vs ROLLING-BLOCK-RIFLE→NAVY-REVOLVER vs CARCANO-RIFLE→

Weapon Familiarity and Condition

Weapons perform better the more you use them.

Stat Ratings

Damage

Base power before ammo modifiers.

Ammo Types

Express ammo provides a sheer damage boost.

Frequently Asked Questions

Most damage?+

The Elephant Rifle hits the hardest.

Methodology & Data Integrity

All calculations are based on verified data extracted from Red Dead Redemption 2 Patch 1.32 game files. We cross-reference values with in-game testing to ensure 99.9% accuracy for competitive play.