RDR2 Complete Weapons Database

📊 Detailed Analysis: Cattleman Revolver vs Otis Miller's Revolver in Red Dead Redemption 2

Comparing the Cattleman Revolver vs the Otis Miller's Revolver, key metrics separate the two. The Otis Miller's Revolver dominates the critical time-to-kill metric with a blistering 1.200s over its rival's 1.333s. In terms of raw damage, the Otis Miller's Revolver pulls ahead with 138 DPS against 120 DPS. The Cattleman Revolver takes 5 shots to drop a target, while the Otis Miller's Revolver requires 4 shots.

Mobility & Handling: Both weapons operate at similar movement speeds — positioning and cover usage matter more than weapon weight here.

Situational Use: The Otis Miller's Revolver excels in aggressive push scenarios where TTK dictates the outcome, while the Cattleman Revolver may outperform in defensive long-range holds with its different damage profile.

Data summary: Otis Miller's Revolver wins on TTK by 133ms and on DPS by 18 points. In most standard encounters, these margins are what determine the outcome when both players have equal aim.